Course Review

Fenway Golf Club
Scarsdale, New York
Design, Elegance, Brilliance, Fenway
AMW Faves List
Favorite Par 3 – #4 – short, but certainly not sweet. The yardage tells only part of the story, as the green—defined by a large, sharply contoured two-tiered surface—can be downright brutal.
Favorite Par 4 – #16 – a stunning downhill hole that bends subtly to the right, demanding a drive favoring the left side. The green is open and inviting, allowing for a wide range of shot-making options.
Favorite Par 5 – #3 – classic Tillinghast, highlighted by the infamous Sahara Bunker Complex. The fairway is tightly guarded left and right something he loved to do. Reaching in two offers no assurance of birdie, with a demanding two-tiered green lying in wait.
Favorite Hole Design – #17 – the yardage plays fairly short thanks to the downhill design. Water guards the approach to the green, making it essential to fly the shot all the way to the hole anything landing short risks spinning back into the hazard.
Easiest Hole – #1 – the opening hole at Fenway warmly invites players to settle in and maybe even smile. This short par 4 can be reached in one for the long hitter, and for others, a comfortable short iron awaits for the approach.
Hardest Hole – #12 – a true beast of a par 4, featuring a sweeping dogleg and considerable length that demands two big swings—and more often three—to reach the putting surface.
Favorite Extra Sighting – memorabilia for the Mittelmark Invitational
Favorite Apres Golf – musical on Broadway
Where to Stay – The Opus Westchester, Pendry Natirar, Bedford Post Inn
Where to Eat – Blue Hills at Stone Barns, OKO Rye, Dubrovnik
PLAN AHEAD
Course Details
Address: 384 Old Mamaroneck Road, Scarsdale, NY 10583
Telephone: +1 (914) 723-6000
Website: www.fenwaygolfclub.com
Director of Golf: Tyler Jaramillo
Architect: A.W. Tillinghast; Gil Hanse (restoration)
Year Open: 1924
Greens Fees: ⛳️⛳️⛳️⛳️⛳️
Yardage: Black – 6696; Blue – 6355; Green – 6057; Yellow – 5465; White – 5048
What You Need to Know
It's AMW Story Time!
Coming Soon!
To continue reading please login in or join
To access all of our Course Reviews, Guides, Tips, Lessons, and so much more!